Justice C. Jayachandran allowed the Indian Union Muslim League leader’s petition challenging the first information report, ending proceedings arising from allegations that he accumulated wealth beyond his known income as a legislator.
The court held that the FIR could not be sustained because sanction under Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act had not been obtained. The decision addresses the legality of the criminal proceedings rather than making a factual finding that every questioned asset had been satisfactorily explained.
The case followed a complaint lodged in 2020 by M. R. Harish, a lawyer and Communist Party of India (Marxist) leader. Harish alleged that Shaji had acquired immovable property and constructed a house using funds disproportionate to his earnings.
The allegations concerned wealth accumulated over the period from 2011 to 2020, when Shaji was a member of the Kerala Legislative Assembly. The complaint also questioned expenditure on property purchased in the name of his wife, Asha, and construction of a residence. The combined expenditure was alleged to be approximately Rs 1.62 crore.
On 9 November 2020, the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge in Kozhikode directed the vigilance superintendent of police to secure approval under Section 17A of the anti-corruption law and undertake a preliminary enquiry. Officials obtained approval for that enquiry, and the Legislative Secretary informed Shaji about the process.
The Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau submitted its preliminary findings to the special court. Following consideration of the material, the court ordered registration of a criminal case under provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act dealing with alleged misconduct and possession of disproportionate assets.
Investigators had alleged a 166 per cent increase in Shaji’s assets over a period they examined between 2012 and 2021. A vigilance assessment also alleged unexplained accumulation of approximately Rs 1.47 crore over nine years. Those figures represented the investigating agency’s assertions, not findings established by a criminal trial.
Shaji challenged the FIR, arguing that the legal requirement for sanction had not been satisfied. His petition distinguished the approval obtained for a preliminary enquiry from the sanction required under Section 19, an issue that became central to Thursday’s decision.
The High Court stayed further proceedings in 2023 while examining the challenge. The interim protection was extended, preventing the investigation from advancing through the criminal case pending resolution of his petition.
The order brings an end to the FIR challenged before the court. It does not amount to a trial verdict on the underlying financial allegations, which were never tested through a completed prosecution. The distinction is significant because the ruling turns on compliance with statutory safeguards governing corruption proceedings.
Shaji, a IUML politician serving in Kerala’s United Democratic Front government, had maintained his challenge to the case after assuming ministerial responsibilities. The judgment removes an outstanding criminal proceeding linked to allegations arising from his earlier term as an elected representative.
The assets investigation had also led to a search of Shaji’s residence, during which vigilance officers seized Rs 47.35 lakh in currency. He approached the High Court seeking its return. The court directed that the amount be released against a bank guarantee, subject to the conditions attached to that relief.
A separate allegation involving an alleged Rs 25 lakh payment from an aided school management had formed the basis of another vigilance case.
(The article ‘HC nullifies assets FIR against minister’ appeared first on Free Press Journal.)
Follow Arabian Post
Select Arabian Post as your preferred source on Google and MSN News for trusted business news and Arab politics and updates.