Bradbury-Inspired 451 Error Code Warns of Online Censorship

The Internet Engineering Steering Group (IESG) today approved a new HTTP error code — 451 — that can be used to identify online content that is unavailable for legal reasons, such as government-enforced censorship. Taken from “Farenheit 451,” the title of the classic Ray Bradbury novel about book burning, the error code has been championed for several years by former Google engineer and XML specification author Tim Bray.

Support grew for adopting an HTTP error code designating censored content after London’s High Court in 2012 ordered U.K. Internet service providers to block access to The Pirate Bay digital content-sharing site, which three years earlier had been found in violation of Sweden’s copyright laws. Following the London court ruling, people in Britain who tried to access The Pirate Bay Web site saw a “403” error message indicating that access was forbidden.

“One of the things in the proposal is that the 451 Unavailable for Legal Reasons status is supposed to be accompanied by an explanation of what the legal restrictions are, and what class of sites they apply to,” Bray wrote in a 2012 blog post recounting the origins of his 451 code suggestion.

ADVERTISEMENT

Growing Support for New Code

Mark Nottingham, who chairs the Internet Engineering Task Force’s (IETF) HTTP Working Group, noted after the 451 code won the IESG’s approval that, “effectively you can start using it now.”

In a Friday blog post, Nottingham wrote that he and others had initially resisted the idea of a new error code meant specifically to designate content that can’t be shown for legal reasons. He said his concerns stemmed from the limited number of 4xx codes available, as well as from the fact that there seemed to be other ways such content could be identified.

However, he added, “Tim quietly persisted, occasionally updating the draft and talking to people about it when they asked.”

As support for the new code grew, some sites began using the designation as an experimental way to denote legally blocked content. The U.K.’s Open Rights Group, for example, promoted its stance against blocking orders with the Web site 451Unavailable.org.

Better Tracking of Censorship

Earlier this year, after the IETF’s HTTP Working Group took on the 451 code suggestion as a work item, Bray said he was happy with the direction his proposal had taken.

“Legal demands are increasingly a common problem impeding the flow of data on the Internet, and it deserves its own diagnostic already,” Bray said in April. With some early adopters and the working group exploring the proposal as an idea worth kicking around, “that’s how the Internet gets smoother and better,” he said

Nottingham noted the new error code will also help the building of new systems to track online censorship.

“In some jurisdictions, I suspect that censorious governments will disallow the use of 451, to hide what they’re doing,” he added. “We can’t stop that (of course), but if your government does that, it sends a strong message to you as a citizen about what their intent is. That’s worth knowing about, I think.”

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.


Notice an issue?

Arabian Post strives to deliver the most accurate and reliable information to its readers. If you believe you have identified an error or inconsistency in this article, please don't hesitate to contact our editorial team at editor[at]thearabianpost[dot]com. We are committed to promptly addressing any concerns and ensuring the highest level of journalistic integrity.


ADVERTISEMENT
Just in:
Behomes Launches Behomes Hub – Cashback & Networking App for Real Estate Professionals // CGTN: Beauty in diversity: How wisdom at Nishan Forum inspires global modernization // Musk Alleges Grok Was Misled and Predicts Tech Breakthroughs // MENA Investment Banking Fees Slip Amid Equity Underwriting Lull // Coffee Chains Join Bitcoin Mania with Bold Treasury Moves // Dong Yuhui’s Fujian Journey: The Sea’s Lesson – 30% Destiny, 70% Determination // Nigeria’s Coastal Highway Passes $747 m Funding Milestone // Qingzhen’s Zhanjie Town Leverages Ecological Resources to Drive Industrial Upgrading and Integrate Culture and Tourism for Rural Revitalization // Moroccan‐Born Duo Secures $4.2 Million to Sharpen AI Search Precision // Celebratory 911 Club Coupe Marks Half-Century Porsche Partnership // Caltex Commemorates SG60 with Launch of Limited Edition National Day Picnic Sets // Galaxy AI Elevates On‑Device Intelligence with Privacy at Core // UAE Hits Milestone with EU Delisting From High‑Risk Financial Watchlist // $1 Bn Pact to Launch Digital Real‑World Asset Platform // Motorbike Theft Kingpin Apprehended in Accra // Can India Emerge As The Trusted Leader Of Global South Like Earlier Years? // Golden Bull Award 2025 Winners Revealed // Uweb, the Digital Asset Education Institute, Announces Successful Completion of a US$3 million Angel Funding Round // IIT Delhi and TeamLease EdTech Kick‑start AI for Healthcare Executive Programme // UAE Championing Balanced Oil Markets Through OPEC+ Engagement //