Saturday / August 24.
HomeFT SelectJudge blocks Trump order to deport Muslim migrants

Judge blocks Trump order to deport Muslim migrants

A federal judge has blocked the US government from deporting Muslim migrants and refugees who have been detained at US airports after President Donald Trump issued an order to severely restrict immigration from seven predominantly Muslim nations.

The New York judge ordered the temporary stay after human rights groups sued Mr Trump on behalf of two Iraqi men who were detained on Friday after landing at New York’s JFK airport. Judge Ann Donnelly said the two Iraqi men — and others in the same situation — had a “strong likelihood of success” of proving in court that their right to due process and equal protection had been violated.

Marielena Hincapie, executive director of the National Immigration Law Center, one of the groups that filed the legal challenge, said the stay was a “great first victory by immigrants and refugees against the Trump administration”. She said it was important because a number of other Muslims were being detained at airports across the country.

The Trump administration has sparked massive criticism from across the world over the executive order. Airlines began turning away passengers bound for the US after immigration officers at JFK detained the two Iraqi men who possessed valid visas that they had been recently issued in exchange for having co-operated with the US in Iraq.

Mr Trump signed an order on Friday to create the first stage of the extreme vetting programme he promised during the campaign. It barred refugees from entry for 120 days and indefinitely prohibited entry for Syrian refugees. It also prohibited citizens of seven Muslim nations — Syria, Iraq, Iran, Sudan, Libya, Somalia and Yemen — from entering the US for 90 days.

Speaking in the Oval Office on Saturday evening, Mr Trump defended the ban, which he noted was “not a Muslim ban”.


“It’s working out very, very nicely,” he said. “We’re going to have a very, very strict ban and we’re going to have extreme vetting, which we should have had in this country.”

A Trump administration official said holders of green cards — permanent residents who do not hold citizenship — from the seven impacted countries who were overseas would have to apply for a waiver to return to the US. The official said green card holders in the US would have to meet a consular official before leaving the country. 

Protesters gathered at JFK airport during the day as the New York Taxi Workers Alliance was encouraging its drivers to join the protest. “Drivers stand in solidarity with refugees coming to America in search of peace and safety,” the alliance said. “The president is putting professional drivers in more danger than they have been in any time since 9/11 when hate crimes against immigrants skyrocketed.”

Renée Paradis, a lawyer helping detainees at JFK, welcomed the stay but said that there was some confusion because “it requires those people be admitted, but not that they necessarily be released from detention”. She said there were at least a dozen people who were still being detained at Terminal 4.

Anthony Romero, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union, said the US legal system had worked as “bulwarks against government abuse or unconstitutional policies and orders” and that “Donald Trump suffered his first loss in court”.

The executive order has been lambasted by a wide range of critics, ranging from Google and other companies to human rights groups and some foreign leaders. Justin Trudeau, the Canadian prime minister, said on Twitter that his country would welcome people fleeing persecution, terror and war, adding “diversity is our strength”.

Malala Yousafzai, the 19-year-old Pakistani shot by the Taliban as a school girl who was awarded the Nobel peace prize, said she was “heartbroken” at the move.

“President Trump is closing the door on children, mothers and fathers fleeing violence and war,” she said. “I am heartbroken that America is turning its back on a proud history of welcoming refugees and immigrants — the people who helped build your country, ready to work hard in exchange for a fair chance at a new life.”

Critics have also castigated Mr Trump for saying that Christians from predominantly Muslim nations would receive priority when applying for refugee visas — a move that some argue imposes an unconstitutional religious test.

While Mr Trump signed a range of executive orders in his first week, the vetting programme has had the most immediate tangible impact. The visa ban will not only affect nationals from the seven majority-Muslim nations, but also people from those countries who are travelling on a different country’s passport, a state department official said. It should not affect dual nationality Americans, however. 

During the campaign, Mr Trump called for a complete ban on Muslims entering the US. His rhetoric sparked a harsh reaction from Democrats and many Republicans who said such a move would be unconstitutional. At the time, the critics included Mike Pence, then governor of Indiana who now serves as the US vice-president.

Paul Ryan, the Republican speaker of the House of Representatives who sharply criticised Mr Trump when he proposed a blanket ban, has remained silent, as has Mitch McConnell, the top Republican in the Senate. Ben Sasse, a Republican senator from Nebraska, criticised the executive order as being “too broad”.

“There are two ways to lose our generational battle against jihadism by losing touch with reality,” said Mr Sasse. “The first is to keep pretending that jihadi terrorism has no connection to Islam or to certain countries … And here’s the second way to fail: If we send a signal to the Middle East that the US sees all Muslims as jihadis, the terrorist recruiters win by telling kids that America is banning Muslims and that this is America versus one religion. Both approaches are wrong, and both will make us less safe.” 

Jeff Flake, a Republican senator from Arizona, also criticised the Trump administration. “President Trump and his administration are right to be concerned about national security, but it’s unacceptable when even legal permanent residents are being detained or turned away at airports and ports of entry,” said Mr Flake.

Echoing the same argument, Javad Zarif, the Iranian foreign minister, said the US move was a “great gift” to extremists and their supporters. Iran said it would ban US citizens from entering the country in retaliation, but exempt those who already had visas. In Baghdad, an Iraqi official said some politicians were also pushing for a reciprocal ban.

Mr Trump was praised by Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Geert Wilders, the far-right Dutch populist, who tweeted: “No immigrants from Islamic countries.”

According to the lawsuit that prompted the stay, Hameed Darweesh, one of the two Iraqi men, had received a visa in exchange for having served as an interpreter and engineer for the US in Iraq. The second Iraqi man, Haider Alshawi, received a visa on January 20 to join his wife and son who had already moved to the US as refugees. 

When lawyers representing Mr Darweesh asked Customs and Border Patrol officers at the airport who to contact about the situation, they were told: “Call Mr Trump.”

Additional reporting by Hannah Kuchler, George Parker and Erika Solomon.

Follow Demetri Sevastopulo on Twitter: @dimi

Via FT