Just in:
Universal Language for Healthcare: General Authority Embraces Global Coding System // Andertoons by Mark Anderson for Thu, 28 Mar 2024 // AI Boost for Galaxy Devices: Samsung Expands One UI 6.1 Update // Experts come together to support updating the city’s nature conservation masterplan // Near Miss at Kolkata Airport: IndiGo Plane Makes Contact with Stationary Air India Express // Samsung Partners National Heritage Board to Bring a Slice of Singapore’s Cultural Heritage to Samsung The Frame TV // Sunshine’s Debut Features Leave Tech World Scratching Its Head // Emirates Post Speeds Up Deliveries for GCC with Special Day // Meta Earth Official Website Launch: The Pioneer Explorer in the Modular Public Blockchain Domain // Arvind Kejriwal Was Used By BJP In 2011 Movement To Take On The Congress // Hullabaloo About Electoral Bonds May End Up As A Whimper Pre And Post Poll // Hope for Respite as UAE Endorses UN Plea for Gaza Truce // Arvind Kejriwal Gets International Heft Against The Deshi Vishwaguru // Sharpening the Focus: Sharjah Health Department Refines Evaluation Criteria for “Healthy Schools Programme” // HSBC Streamlines Gold Investment for Hong Kong Residents with Tokenized Product // Konica Minolta is named ASEAN 2023 Market Leader in Colour Light and Mid Digital Production Printers // Superland Announced Annual Results for 2023, 2023 Net Profit Increased approximately 39.5% to approximately HK$22.2 million as Compared to the 2022 Adjusted One // Court Sides with Coinbase on Wallet Service, But Staking Program Remains in Limbo // AIA Hong Kong Wins More Than 20 Accolades at MPF Ratings MPF Awards, BENCHMARK MPF of The Year Awards and Bloomberg Businessweek Top Fund Awards // Ajman Celebrates Conclusion of Ramadan Activities with Grand Ceremony //
HomeMarketsItaly stuck between fiscal grip and ailing banks

Italy stuck between fiscal grip and ailing banks

8e742f2a ba7e 11e6 8b45 b8b81dd5d080

If you set out to make a positive investment case for Italy 20 years ago, the best hope was to play down the myriad structural inefficiencies that blighted the corporate sector and argue that this was a good economy burdened by an unworkable state. Now, after years of no growth accompanied by stubbornly high public debt, a positive case looks even harder to make, especially after the No vote in Sunday’s referendum on the constitution.

In such circumstances history can help. Two overwhelming events have been substantially responsible for derailing the Italian economy. The first is membership of the European monetary union. Before 1999, Italy habitually responded to competitiveness problems by devaluing the lira. Thereafter, internal devaluation through declining real wages was the only available option.

ADVERTISEMENT

At the same time, any resort to fiscal expansion was constrained by the stability and growth pact rules. For many years Italy, far from being the profligate spender of northern European imagination, has run a primary budget surplus before interest, with the sole exception of 2009. Its daunting level of public sector debt, currently about 133 per cent of gross domestic product, is essentially a legacy of the high-spending 1980s. It remains high for want of economic growth. The International Monetary Fund does not expect a return to pre-2007 output levels before the mid-2020s. Meantime the fiscal straitjacket means that the country has limited ability to respond to shocks, notably from an ailing banking system.

The twin uncertainties of the referendum and a high level of non-performing loans in banking have caused capital to flee the country. Policy options to address capital flight are also cut short by membership of the monetary union. The European Central Bank sets interest rates by reference to the eurozone as a whole. It cannot plug a capital leak in Italy. Nor can the Banca d’Italia defend (or not defend) the currency. All it can do when official reserves run out is borrow to maintain its euro peg under Target 2, the settlement system for the euro. As of September, Italy’s Target 2 balance was above 20 per cent of GDP, its worst reading to date. On standard definitions of financial distress these are crisis-level reserve losses, according to Carmen Reinhart of Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government.

The other big trauma came when China joined the World Trade Organisation in 2001. Italy was more exposed than most to Chinese competition because its exports were heavily concentrated in price sensitive, low value added goods. As Shweta Singh of Lombard Street Research points out, this was a natural result of using devaluation — that is, cheapening exports — as the chief tool of demand management for so long before 1999. The result is that Italy’s share of global exports has plummeted. The loss of competitiveness was exacerbated by sluggish productivity, reflecting a worsening of the structural inefficiencies that have long been a drag on the economy.

Much of the anti-establishment populist protest around Europe comes from those in society who have been left behind by globalisation. In the case of Italy it is the whole country that has been left behind. Small wonder that the campaigns of the main challenger parties, the Five Star Movement and the Northern League, resonated on Sunday with an electorate desperate to snub the political establishment. Both favour abandoning the euro. The threat that Italy poses to the survival of the monetary union in its present shape has thus increased, albeit from a low level, against a background of greater political uncertainty following the offer of resignation from Prime Minister Matteo Renzi.

Today it might be possible to make a short-term case that Italian government debt is oversold. Any additional risk premium for these uncertainties has probably already been built into Italian asset prices. The economy will continue to benefit from Trump-induced strength of the dollar against the euro and from the probable extension of the ECB’s unconventional measures at its meeting on Thursday. A domino theory for the eurozone, starting with Italy, looks needlessly alarmist — for now. Structural reform nonetheless looks more elusive after the referendum and further recapitalisation of the banking system more difficult.

ADVERTISEMENT

Italy is a country that historically has galvanised itself in response to big shocks, but seems able to pursue incremental reform only at a glacial pace. Sunday’s result was simply not big enough to transform the economic prospect.

[email protected]

Source link

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT
Just in:
HSBC Streamlines Gold Investment for Hong Kong Residents with Tokenized Product // Infineon and HD Korea Shipbuilding & Offshore Engineering jointly develop ship electrification technology // Experience Ultimate Shopping Freedom at 4.4 Shopee Spree: Don’t Worry, Shop Shopee! // Andertoons by Mark Anderson for Thu, 28 Mar 2024 // Near Miss at Kolkata Airport: IndiGo Plane Makes Contact with Stationary Air India Express // No running of govt from jail, says Delhi Lt Governor // German Job Market Resilience Bodes Well for Economic Recovery // Samsung Partners National Heritage Board to Bring a Slice of Singapore’s Cultural Heritage to Samsung The Frame TV // Konica Minolta is named ASEAN 2023 Market Leader in Colour Light and Mid Digital Production Printers // Arvind Kejriwal Gets International Heft Against The Deshi Vishwaguru // In Lok Sabha Polls In Punjab, AAP Is Advantageously Placed As Against Its Three Rivals // Lisboeta Macau’s world first LINE FRIENDS PRESENTS CASA DE AMIGO and BROWN & FRIENDS CAFE & BISTRO has officially opened // Emirates Post Speeds Up Deliveries for GCC with Special Day // Meta Earth Official Website Launch: The Pioneer Explorer in the Modular Public Blockchain Domain // U.S. Compliance Takes Center Stage at OKX Following Industry Jitters // Arvind Kejriwal Was Used By BJP In 2011 Movement To Take On The Congress // Court Sides with Coinbase on Wallet Service, But Staking Program Remains in Limbo // Renewables Surge Sets Record, But Global Equity Lags // Superland Announced Annual Results for 2023, 2023 Net Profit Increased approximately 39.5% to approximately HK$22.2 million as Compared to the 2022 Adjusted One // Sunshine’s Debut Features Leave Tech World Scratching Its Head //