Just in:
Ingdan Announces 2023 Annual Results // Arvind Kejriwal Gets International Heft Against The Deshi Vishwaguru // In Lok Sabha Polls In Punjab, AAP Is Advantageously Placed As Against Its Three Rivals // Lisboeta Macau’s world first LINE FRIENDS PRESENTS CASA DE AMIGO and BROWN & FRIENDS CAFE & BISTRO has officially opened // Emirates Post Speeds Up Deliveries for GCC with Special Day // Global Audience to Witness Thrill of Dubai World Cup // Experience Ultimate Shopping Freedom at 4.4 Shopee Spree: Don’t Worry, Shop Shopee! // Party Nominees Refusing To Contest: Major Perception Threat For BJP // Infineon and HD Korea Shipbuilding & Offshore Engineering jointly develop ship electrification technology // German Job Market Resilience Bodes Well for Economic Recovery // Hope for Respite as UAE Endorses UN Plea for Gaza Truce // AI Boost for Galaxy Devices: Samsung Expands One UI 6.1 Update // Experts come together to support updating the city’s nature conservation masterplan // Ajman Celebrates Conclusion of Ramadan Activities with Grand Ceremony // Konica Minolta is named ASEAN 2023 Market Leader in Colour Light and Mid Digital Production Printers // Sunshine’s Debut Features Leave Tech World Scratching Its Head // AIA Hong Kong Wins More Than 20 Accolades at MPF Ratings MPF Awards, BENCHMARK MPF of The Year Awards and Bloomberg Businessweek Top Fund Awards // Court Sides with Coinbase on Wallet Service, But Staking Program Remains in Limbo // Andertoons by Mark Anderson for Thu, 28 Mar 2024 // Emirati Aid Reaches Ukraine as Food Shortages Bite //
HomeMiddle EastMecca Shows How Crowds, Usually Calm in Crisis, Can Panic

Mecca Shows How Crowds, Usually Calm in Crisis, Can Panic

Contrary to common portrayals of the madding crowd, people caught in an unfolding catastrophe usually summon their best selves, keep cool heads and look out for those around them, according to decades of research into crowd reactions during earthquakes, fires, floods, bombings and other threats.

It had not been reported exactly what touched off the panic that killed more than 700 people on Thursday near Mecca, Saudi Arabia, or whether deficient crowd-control measures may have been to blame.

Even so, the disaster is a reminder that in some circumstances, the strong social roles that help preserve lives in most crises can break down.

ADVERTISEMENT

The huge number of hajj pilgrims — an estimated two million this year — probably played a role, especially since the area around Mecca would not be familiar ground for most of them. Sheer numbers can overwhelm a person’s sense of space, of where you are and where you are going.

Map | How the Hajj Stampede Unfolded Maps showing where more than 700 people were killed in a stampede near Mecca, Saudi Arabia.

“There’s absolutely no sense of shared infrastructure” in such a situation, said Lee Clarke, a sociologist at Rutgers University and author of “Worst Cases,” a history of crowd behavior in the face of threat and catastrophe. By contrast, he said, “you can have 40,000, 50,000 or 80,000 people trying to exit a football stadium at the same time, and people know how to act in that system because there’s a shared sense of where the ramps are leading, where the exits are, where the gates are.”

Research by Dr. Clarke and others has confirmed what most people feel instinctively when they are in a tightly packed and nervous crowd: If escape routes are blocked or dwindling, fear begins to color every decision. Caught in the middle of a large enough crowd, people may see no way out.

That was an apparent cause of a mass panic that killed 21 people at a music festival in Duisburg, Germany, in July 2010, Dr. Clarke said. Police officers at the festival tried to reverse the flow of a crowd, and people were trapped near a tunnel entrance, unable to move in any direction, according to reports on the event.

ADVERTISEMENT

Another instance occurred in Cincinnati before a 1979 concert by The Who. Fans outside the arena who were afraid the concert was starting without them swarmed toward a row of entrance doors and panicked when the doors were kept locked, shutting off any escape for those at the front of the crowd. Eleven people died in the shoving.

The composition of the crowd can also be a factor. Large religious events tend to attract thousands of people who are elderly and have difficulty bearing the heat, fatigue and the jostling of crowds. Government scientists in India found in a recent study that almost 80 percent of “mass gathering emergencies” in that country occurred during religious festivals.

In a large crowd, other dynamics that undermine social collaboration can develop, especially when the crowd is culturally diverse and in motion.

One is a surge with no apparent cause. It may have originated hundreds of yards away with a bit of pushing, or even simply people stopping to rest, but it can amplify and reach most of the crowd like a rogue wave, powerful and seemingly random.

“Think of being in traffic on the highway, stopping and starting, and there’s no accident, no police, no source at all,” said George Loewenstein, a professor of economics and psychology at Carnegie Mellon University. “In large crowds, especially if they’re somehow contained, a small disruption in one place can cause larger chaos far away, for reasons no one there understands.”

People’s natural instinct toward social cohesion may be weaker in some crowds than others, research suggests. Anthony R. Mawson of Jackson State University found that people’s behavior in mass panic events depends in part on the whereabouts of “familiar persons,” meaning friends and family.

“Their physical presence has a calming effect and reduces the probability” of a fight-or-flight response, he concluded, “while their absence has the opposite effect.”

People who have been caught at packed events like rock concerts know that this instinct can extend to other fans nearby, the clutch of 10 to 20 people who may bond, if temporarily, during a show. The vast diversity of the crowds near Mecca, with pilgrims from all over the world, may make such spontaneous groups less likely to form there.

“This is such a heterogeneous mass of people, of all different ages, languages and cultures,” Dr. Loewenstein said. “Despite the shared religion, communication could have been very difficult.”

Little sense of space, no clear escape, rogue waves of motion among people who have difficulty communicating — those are conditions when collaboration can turn to desperation, and blind panic can spread.

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.

(via NY Times)

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT
Just in:
Samsung Partners National Heritage Board to Bring a Slice of Singapore’s Cultural Heritage to Samsung The Frame TV // Ingdan Announces 2023 Annual Results // Renewables Surge Sets Record, But Global Equity Lags // Emirati Aid Reaches Ukraine as Food Shortages Bite // Meta Earth Official Website Launch: The Pioneer Explorer in the Modular Public Blockchain Domain // Sunshine’s Debut Features Leave Tech World Scratching Its Head // Superland Announced Annual Results for 2023, 2023 Net Profit Increased approximately 39.5% to approximately HK$22.2 million as Compared to the 2022 Adjusted One // Party Nominees Refusing To Contest: Major Perception Threat For BJP // Emirates Post Speeds Up Deliveries for GCC with Special Day // Arvind Kejriwal Gets International Heft Against The Deshi Vishwaguru // Infineon and HD Korea Shipbuilding & Offshore Engineering jointly develop ship electrification technology // Ajman Celebrates Conclusion of Ramadan Activities with Grand Ceremony // Experts come together to support updating the city’s nature conservation masterplan // AIA Hong Kong Wins More Than 20 Accolades at MPF Ratings MPF Awards, BENCHMARK MPF of The Year Awards and Bloomberg Businessweek Top Fund Awards // Hope for Respite as UAE Endorses UN Plea for Gaza Truce // US reiterates concern over Kejriwal arrest, Cong accounts // Experience Ultimate Shopping Freedom at 4.4 Shopee Spree: Don’t Worry, Shop Shopee! // Universal Language for Healthcare: General Authority Embraces Global Coding System // Konica Minolta is named ASEAN 2023 Market Leader in Colour Light and Mid Digital Production Printers // German Job Market Resilience Bodes Well for Economic Recovery //