Just in:
Universal Language for Healthcare: General Authority Embraces Global Coding System // CABSAT 2024 Ushers in 30 Years of Media Innovation // Aid is at the core of Israel, Palestine struggle to control post-war Gaza // 2024 Lok Sabha Elections Will Be The Costliest One Till Now In The Whole World // Saudi Arabia Unveils Green Financing Tool to Achieve Net-Zero Goals // Samsung Electronics Launches 2024 Neo QLED 8K, Neo QLED, and OLED Displays to Spark the AI Screen Era // TUMI Hosts Global Launch Event in Singapore to Unveil Women’s Asra Collection and Announce Global Ambassador, Mun Ka Young // UAE Golden Gambit to Counter Saudi Bid for Business Leadership // Global Audience to Witness Thrill of Dubai World Cup // Emirati Aid Reaches Ukraine as Food Shortages Bite // Experience Ultimate Shopping Freedom at 4.4 Shopee Spree: Don’t Worry, Shop Shopee! // U.S. Compliance Takes Center Stage at OKX Following Industry Jitters // A Tightrope Saudi Walk Towards Net-Zero // German Job Market Resilience Bodes Well for Economic Recovery // First-Ever Fortune Innovation Forum Draws Top Global Leaders to Hong Kong, Promoting Agendas On Collective Cross-Sector Advancement // Melco Style Presents “SANRIO CHARACTERS STUDIO CITY CARNIVAL” – Explore a SANRIO World of Unlimited Love and Cuteness // US reiterates concern over Kejriwal arrest, Cong accounts // Sunshine’s Debut Features Leave Tech World Scratching Its Head // Ingdan Announces 2023 Annual Results // Samsung Partners National Heritage Board to Bring a Slice of Singapore’s Cultural Heritage to Samsung The Frame TV //
HomeWorldMay's Brexit plans face British Supreme Court test

May's Brexit plans face British Supreme Court test

By Michael Holden
| LONDON

ADVERTISEMENT

LONDON Prime Minister Theresa May’s government launches a challenge on Monday against a court ruling that it requires parliamentary approval to start the process of leaving the European Union, a decision that could upset Britain’s Brexit plans.

If the Supreme Court, the United Kingdom’s highest judicial body, dismisses the government appeal it could derail May’s timetable for triggering Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty and leaving the EU.

ADVERTISEMENT

The government’s legal fight comes against a backdrop of claims by some politicians and newspapers that establishment judges want to thwart the Brexit process.

It will be the most high-profile and complex case the court has considered since it came into being seven years ago and is due to last for four days. For the first time all its 11 justices will sit on the panel with the verdict due later in January.

“The case raises difficult and delicate issues about the constitutional relationship between government and parliament,” Brenda Hale, the Supreme Court’s Vice-President said in a speech last month.

“What is meant by the exercise of the executive power of the state? We do not have a written constitution to tell us the answer. But I doubt whether many written constitutions would tell us the answer either.”

If May wins, she can proceed with her plans to invoke Article 50 by the end of March.

But if she loses, parliament could in theory block Brexit as most lawmakers (MPs) supported staying in the EU in a referendum in June, though few observers expect such an outcome. Even so, lawmaker approval could open the process to greater scrutiny and delay.

Investors believe the greater parliament’s involvement the less chance there is of a “hard Brexit” in which tight controls on immigration are prioritised over European single market access. The pound surged after November’s High Court ruling.

In a sign of how thorny the process could be for May, the opposition Labour Party plans to table an amendment to any Article 50 bill to try to keep market access to the bloc, its leader Jeremy Corbyn told Sky News on Saturday.

The addition of amendments could risk derailing May’s timetable, although the BBC has reported that the government has prepared a very short bill which would be “bomb-proof” against changes by lawmakers who may try and add conditions to the approval.

Meanwhile the pro-EU Liberal Democrat party says it would vote against Article 50 unless there is a new referendum on the final Brexit deal, a concession May is highly unlikely to make.

The party won a ninth seat in parliament on Thursday in a local by-election vote.

The High Court challenge was brought by investment fund manager Gina Miller with hairdresser Deir Tozetti Dos Santos the second claimant.

Other parties will also be allowed to offer legal arguments this week, including the devolved Welsh government, a group of expatriate Britons, and the Independent Workers Union of Great Britain which represents mainly low-paid migrant workers.

So too will the Scottish government, which strongly opposes Brexit and has been seeking ways to keep Scotland in the EU.

The case hinges on whether the government can use a historical power known as “royal prerogative” to invoke Article 50 without lawmakers’ assent.

USEFUL DISTRACTION?

The challengers argued that Britons would inevitably lose rights granted under an act of parliament when leaving the EU, and that under Britain’s unwritten constitution such rights could only be taken away with parliamentary approval.

The High Court agreed with this, rejecting the government’s assertion parliament had given its approval by allowing a referendum and that it was established the executive alone could make or leave international treaties.

The government’s prepared argument for the Supreme Court is little changed from before. Miller has told Reuters she suspected May might be happy to lose, with the court battle providing a useful distraction to ministerial divisions and Brexit indecision.

June’s vote to leave the EU exposed deep divisions in Britain, and some pro-Brexit politicians condemned the High Court for flouting democracy. The Daily Mail newspaper called the three senior judges involved “enemies of the people”.

Miller herself has become a target of hate and has received abuse and death threats.

Some lawmakers in May’s Conservative Party have also called for Supreme Court President David Neuberger to stand down because his wife had posted anti-Brexit messages on Twitter.

One of the court’s justices, Brian Kerr, said judges would not be swayed by personal views.

“That’s not to say we don’t have personal views, but we are all extremely conscious of the need to set aside our personal views and apply the law as we conceive it to be,” he told the BBC last month.

Meanwhile, upsetting the media, politicians and some of the public is unlikely to faze Neuberger and the other justices.

“Parliament no doubt appreciates that the unelected judges sometimes are more easily able to do what is right, but temporarily unpopular, than politicians who need to submit themselves at least every five years to the electorate,” Neuberger said in a 2011 speech.

(Additional reporting by Sarah Young, Editing by Richard Lough)

-Reuters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT
Just in:
U.S. Compliance Takes Center Stage at OKX Following Industry Jitters // Sunshine’s Debut Features Leave Tech World Scratching Its Head // Emirati Aid Reaches Ukraine as Food Shortages Bite // Saudi Arabia Unveils Green Financing Tool to Achieve Net-Zero Goals // New Nylon Constant Torque Hinge From Southco Provides Position Control In A Compact Package // Ingdan Announces 2023 Annual Results // Sharjah Chamber Breaks Ground on Final Expansion with New HQ Pact // TUMI Hosts Global Launch Event in Singapore to Unveil Women’s Asra Collection and Announce Global Ambassador, Mun Ka Young // Hong Kong Crypto Exchange Application Stalled by US Lawsuit // Simplified Business Moves for Al Reem Island Firms // A Tightrope Saudi Walk Towards Net-Zero // UAE Golden Gambit to Counter Saudi Bid for Business Leadership // CABSAT 2024 Ushers in 30 Years of Media Innovation // Samsung Partners National Heritage Board to Bring a Slice of Singapore’s Cultural Heritage to Samsung The Frame TV // French Leaders Gather for Interfaith Iftar Dinner // Following the Money Trail: US and UK Investigate $20 Billion in USDT Transfers Tied to Sanctioned Russian Exchange // Andertoons by Mark Anderson for Fri, 29 Mar 2024 // Melco Style Presents “SANRIO CHARACTERS STUDIO CITY CARNIVAL” – Explore a SANRIO World of Unlimited Love and Cuteness // Samsung Electronics Launches 2024 Neo QLED 8K, Neo QLED, and OLED Displays to Spark the AI Screen Era // First-Ever Fortune Innovation Forum Draws Top Global Leaders to Hong Kong, Promoting Agendas On Collective Cross-Sector Advancement //